There was this question raised against me in full throttle by one of my newly wed friend, when I questioned her ignorance to deeply understand, analyze & accept the likings, disliking & attitude of in-laws at her new house… “why can’t they let me do things im comfortable with?” ....really tickled my thoughts… Did i ask her to compromise because there’s an unknown trace of male chauvinism somewhere hidden in me?? OR do I have a mysterious liking which im not aware of, for a joint family??? Donno…. However, so much into the habit of arguments nowadays, which I think should cut down drastically… well, what I wanted to scribble was whether nuclear families have an EMOTIONAL edge over joint families...
~
I guess in olden days, family was the basic political, religious, social, and economic unit in society, and, as such, was both a public and a private institution. It educated the young, served as the first level of government, and cared for the sick, the elderly, and the disabled. And the father figure held a position of supreme authority over his wife, children, and all other dependents living in the household. Probably this concept of authority and dependency created an inclusive definition of the family. Everyone subject to the authority of the householder was considered a member -- immediate relatives, dependent kin, hired help, tenants, servants, apprentices…. Even an individual could be a member of several families during his or her lifetime. One might grow up in one family, apprentice in an other, work as a journeyman or maid servant in another, set up a business, get married and become head or mistress of one's own family, and in old age become a dependent in someone else's home…. all were part of the joint family system
~
The fact is, an increasing number of people are now rejecting the traditional notion of the Indian joint family system, and are trying to use cultural, social and public reasons to promote their assertion that the joint families are just a social convention, an invention that might have been good for the pre 1990s, but is now as outdated….
Well… gets confused when I sank more into the topic…. But, Yes…. I do think nuclear family is better than Joint family for the times we live in.... But this does not imply we break relations with our family members. Some how we know that two women, whether it be puja, priya, prema or even sisters , they just can't go along together, this is the nature of women which nobody can change, Even if one is good , the other won't be. So in order to avoid all this bitterness, it is better to have separate kitchen's so that later on we dont have to spoil relationships. I think even today's women do not have that same strength to bear the burden of joint family, which our grandmother's had......... { hope julie doesn't see this, OR ELSE will have to start eatin' junk from outside, hehehe.... is there any trace of chauvinism in me???? Naaaah, isn’t it :))))) }
~
I believe.... its the people who make a family...... If the members have a feeling of belongingness and they are attached, then the whole world is in their family..... So joint families will be better for people who want to have all the relations.... feel more attachments.... who wants to share joys n sorrows together..... and never want to be alone…. Rather lonely (hahaha, thanx dear….)
~
I guess in olden days, family was the basic political, religious, social, and economic unit in society, and, as such, was both a public and a private institution. It educated the young, served as the first level of government, and cared for the sick, the elderly, and the disabled. And the father figure held a position of supreme authority over his wife, children, and all other dependents living in the household. Probably this concept of authority and dependency created an inclusive definition of the family. Everyone subject to the authority of the householder was considered a member -- immediate relatives, dependent kin, hired help, tenants, servants, apprentices…. Even an individual could be a member of several families during his or her lifetime. One might grow up in one family, apprentice in an other, work as a journeyman or maid servant in another, set up a business, get married and become head or mistress of one's own family, and in old age become a dependent in someone else's home…. all were part of the joint family system
~
The fact is, an increasing number of people are now rejecting the traditional notion of the Indian joint family system, and are trying to use cultural, social and public reasons to promote their assertion that the joint families are just a social convention, an invention that might have been good for the pre 1990s, but is now as outdated….
Well… gets confused when I sank more into the topic…. But, Yes…. I do think nuclear family is better than Joint family for the times we live in.... But this does not imply we break relations with our family members. Some how we know that two women, whether it be puja, priya, prema or even sisters , they just can't go along together, this is the nature of women which nobody can change, Even if one is good , the other won't be. So in order to avoid all this bitterness, it is better to have separate kitchen's so that later on we dont have to spoil relationships. I think even today's women do not have that same strength to bear the burden of joint family, which our grandmother's had......... { hope julie doesn't see this, OR ELSE will have to start eatin' junk from outside, hehehe.... is there any trace of chauvinism in me???? Naaaah, isn’t it :))))) }
~
I believe.... its the people who make a family...... If the members have a feeling of belongingness and they are attached, then the whole world is in their family..... So joint families will be better for people who want to have all the relations.... feel more attachments.... who wants to share joys n sorrows together..... and never want to be alone…. Rather lonely (hahaha, thanx dear….)
~
"The more elaborate our means of communication, the less we communicate"
4 comments:
hahaha... franco... i've got so much money that im more interested in makin it lose over internet(guys, sameer.... doesn't make any diff. between america & india.... run, network marketin' is here too....)
franco... plz don't take revenge on me by spamming... thanx
Atul, actually that post by Franco is an automated spam post.
And you are replying to that! lol!
Talking about joint family.... well the original Indian culture is based on patience and tolerance... So you never walk out from the family just because you are not able to get well along with another one... But these days... all are becoming too selfish and worry only about their own comfort....
"the original Indian culture is based on patience and tolerance..."
true sameer... thatz a very vital point i left out there... thanx for bringin' it up... true, thatz supposed to be de base of all indian family relationships.... somehow i missed those very important words... thanx
oops.... i didn't realise dat :))
Post a Comment